NPS returns vary across funds and fund managers, how and when to review your investments

    ​Should you change your NPS fund manager?
    1/6

    ​Should you change your NPS fund manager?

    Due to the erstwhile indexation rules, several NPS schemes generated similar returns and therefore, cross comparing schemes was not on the list of investors' worries. However, after the gradual elimination of indexing rules, fund managers started generating diverse returns, pushing investors to compare returns in this space also. Even the value of investment of Rs 5,000 a month over 5 years varies widely across funds.

    NPS as an investment tool has matured now and there is enough historical data to analyse and help you decide whether you want to continue with the same fund manager or not. The divergence in returns means subscribers should review their investments.

    Getty Images
    ​When to review
    2/6

    ​When to review

    NPS subscribers should assess their funds and fund managers regularly, because even minor differences now will amplify in the long-term, obviously due to the power of compounding. So experts suggest that you should conduct annual reviews of your NPS portfolios also like you do for your mutual fund investments.

    Just like other investment options, these reviews can also be based on specific events. While there is no need to react to all news breaks, you need to review if there is any fundamental change, including a shift in fund management, change of management style, among others events, even though such incidents are very rare in case of NPS.

    Getty Images
    ​3 steps to review
    3/6

    ​3 steps to review

    Since NPS is also NAV driven and linked to market forces, its review process can be similar to that of mutual funds. First, see whether your fund manager is underperforming others. This comparison should not be based on short term returns of 1-3 months, but on a reasonable long period like 1-3 years. This exercise will help you decide whether you should review your NPS manager or not. This is not to mean that you should just shift because of a year of underperformance, but certainly review it.

    Getty Images
    ​Detected underperformance?
    4/6

    ​Detected underperformance?

    If at all you come to realise that your fund manager is underperforming, the next step is to get into its reasons. Could this be attributed to a particular strategy? Get a financial planner or investment advisor if you feel unsure doing this yourself.

    Getty Images
    ​All or nothing condition
    5/6

    ​All or nothing condition

    Tax efficiency in such fund manager shifts is one of the biggest advantages of NPS. While shifting from one mutual fund to another will result in a tax incidence, switching between fund managers will be tax neutral in NPS due to its open architecture. However, NPS places a restriction here— you can be with only one fund manager.

    Getty Images
    ​Review asset allocation also
    6/6

    ​Review asset allocation also

    Just like the annual fund manager reviews, experts also recommend overall asset allocation reviews on a regular basis. How frequently should one do that? Or rather, how often can you do that? NPS has the restriction in place that you are allowed to shift between schemes only twice a year. So twice a year you must review and if needed, carry out the shifts between schemes.

    Getty Images
    Read more on
    The Economic Times
    User